Cleveland woman missing since New Year’s Day found dead

Police and community 'saddened by the outcome'

Mattie Mizell

The search for a Cleveland, Georgia, woman missing since New Year’s Day ended tragically on Thursday when searchers found the body of Mattie Mizell. White County Coroner Ricky Barrett confirmed the 69-year-old’s death.

Mizell was captured on surveillance cameras as she walked around Cleveland on New Year’s Day (photo from Cleveland Police Dept.)

“We don’t know how long she was dead, cause of death or anything like that – we don’t know right yet,” Barrett told Now Habersham. He said he will confer with the State Medical Examiner’s office on Friday.

The Cleveland Police Department, which led the exhaustive six-day search for Mizell, released a statement late on January 6 saying her body was found that evening along the edge of a creek in a densely wooded area.

“Foul play is not suspected,” said Cleveland Police Chief Jeff Shoemaker.

The discovery came on the heels of an exhaustive six-day search that began January first when Mizell, who had dementia, went for a walk and never returned home. She was captured on surveillance cameras and spotted by residents in several locations on New Year’s Day. The last known sighting of her was in the area of NOK Drive northeast of Cleveland.

Exhaustive search

Ground crews and tracking dogs spent days searching the outlying areas near where Mizell was seen. Search teams used drones and helicopters to check adjacent waterways and areas difficult to access by foot, officials said.

On Tuesday, Chief Shoemaker released a photo of a pickup truck seen on NOK Drive around the same time as Mizell. Officials were looking for the driver, hoping to speak with them to find out if they saw anything. As of Wednesday evening, police were still looking for that driver.

Police released this photo of a pickup truck, hoping to speak with its driver. (photo Cleveland Police Dept.)

The search for Mizell gained statewide attention. News stations across Georgia covered the story and thousands of people shared social media posts and articles about the search for the missing woman. They shared the hope, too, that she would be found safe.

“We are heartbroken with the outcome of this case. It is not the outcome anyone in our community was hoping for,” said Cleveland Mayor Josh Turner. “On behalf of the City of Cleveland and our partners, I would like to extend sincere and heartfelt condolences to the Mizell family. This is an incredibly difficult time for Mrs. Mizell’s family and the community.”

As invested as the public was in this case, none were more invested than those public safety officials and volunteers who searched for Mattie Mizell. Personnel from multiple local and state agencies including the Cleveland Police Department, White County Public Safety Department, Georgia State Patrol, Georgia Department of Natural Resources, Georgia Emergency Management Agency, and Georgia Department of Defense were involved in the search. Barrett said they should be commended because they never gave up.

“Nobody stopped looking for her. They just kept on,” he told Now Habersham. “They had resources from everywhere looking for her and they stayed with it.”

Searchers used drones to try and locate Mattie Mizell. The 69-year-old Cleveland woman, who police say had dementia, walked away from her home on New Year’s Day and never returned. (photo by wrwh.com)
Low cloud cover grounded search helicopters in the area of NOK Drive in Cleveland on Monday, Jan. 3, 2022. (Hadley Cottingham/Now Habersham)
Officials set up a command post during the search at the White County Middle School gym. Mizell was seen walking near the school the day she went missing. (Hadley Cottingham/Now Habersham)
Cleveland Police Chief Jeff Shoemaker (left), White County Fire Chief Seth Weaver (right) discuss the search with state law enforcement officials. (Hadley Cottingham/Now Habersham)

“The police department would like to thank members of the community who assisted in the search,” Chief Shoemaker said. “We are all saddened by the outcome; our thoughts and prayers are with the family of Mrs. Mizell.”

Mizell’s family has asked for the public to respect their privacy and will make no statements regarding the matter, the police chief said. He also said they will not be receiving visitors at this time, adding, anyone may contact the Cleveland Police Department at 706-348-7078.

This article has been updated with the latest information